New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research abstracts
Evaluation of Enterolertreg. for the enumeration of
enterococci in the marine environment
STAN ABBOTT
BRIAN CAUGHLEY
GUY SCOTT
Wellington Polytechnic
Private Box 756
Wellington, New Zealand
email: stan.abbott@wnp.ac.nz
Abstract Current methods for the analyses of enterococcal
densities include the membrane filtration (MF) technique and the multiple tube
fermentation technique for the most probable number (MPN). Both techniques are
labour intensive, tedious, and require a minimum of 48-72 h before results
can be obtained. The Enterolert
reg. system, designed to
detect enterococci in water in 24 h, uses
4-methylumbelliferyl-ß-D-glucoside as a defined substrate nutrient
indicator. This compound, when hydrolysed by enterococcal-ß-glucosidase,
releases 4-methylumbelliferone which exhibits fluorescence under a UV365 lamp.
In this study 343 marine water samples from selected sites in the Wellington
area of New Zealand were tested to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of
Enterolert in parallel with the MF method. Statistical analysis of parallel
test results showed a strong linear correlation (
r = 0.927) and no
significant difference between the two methods by paired
t-test analysis
(
P = 0.39). Based on the 2.4% false positive and 0.3% false negative
rates, Enterolert was found to have a sensitivity of 99.8% and a specificity of
97.0%. Activity-costing analyses revealed that the variable cost per test was
less for Enterolert (NZ$18.33) than MF (NZ$22.79). Significant time savings are
achieved because Enterolert requires less time than MF for reagent preparation,
sample set-up, incubation, and reading of tests. The results from this study
suggest that more widespread use of this new technology in marine water quality
monitoring is warranted, since rapid tests mean that monitoring agencies can
respond to sudden increases in enterococci numbers more quickly and can
therefore take immediate corrective action to ensure the safety of users of
recreational waters.
Keywords enumerating enterococci; marine water;
Enterolertreg.; defined substrate technology;
enterococcal-ß-glucosidase; quanti-tray(TM); 4-methylumbelliferone
fluorescence; membrane filtration; most probable number; rapid test; linear
correlation; cost analyses; recreational water quality
M98021
Received 12 May 1998; accepted 9 July 1998
PDF file of entire paper: medium quality (774K); (scanned from paper original: notes about this process)
This year's abstracts |
Journal home page |
All abstracts |
Publishing home page