Home page Top menu bar
   
191 pixel spacer

MARSDEN FUND NEWSLETTER

NO 20 June 2002

Contents

Protein crosslinking - the chemistry of cataracts and croissants

Tuatara survivors

News from Marsden Cottage

Using DNA to track dolphin and whale populations

Bringing together museums and indigenous knowledge

Marsden recognised in Queen's Birthday honours

Frozen weta


Protein crosslinking - the chemistry of cataracts and croissants


Formation of cataracts is a welll-documented
deleterious consequence of protein crosslinking via
the Mailard reaction
Proteins are often dubbed "the agents of metabolic function". They are the workhorses of biology, vital to virtually all biological processes. To fill such an enormous number of important roles, proteins must be very versatile. Each has a complex and precise structure, ideally suited to perform particular chemistry. The relationship between the structure and function of a protein is a delicate one, which is easily disrupted. Chemical modification of proteins can profoundly change their function, and is of fundamental importance in many spheres.
Marsden-funded research carried out by Dr Juliet Gerrard's team at Canterbury University has focused on a particular form of protein modification - protein crosslinking. Her specific interest is the reaction of proteins with sugars, a complex process known as the Maillard reaction. This reaction yields a multitude of products generally dubbed advanced glycation end products - AGEs. These accumulate in the body as we grow old and so are appropriately named.
Proteins are generally surrounded by sugars in biological systems, and the consequences of protein crosslinking chemistry by the Maillard reaction can be enormous. These reactions have been implicated in many diseases, especially in diabetes where there is more sugar in the blood and, therefore, a higher chance of crosslinking taking place. Another condition in which crosslinking is implicated is Alzheimer's disease. Sufferers are often found to have tangles of protein in their brain, which alter neuronal pathways. Crosslinking in these protein aggregates makes the situation worse, as the body is unable to destroy the unwanted proteins.
Another dramatic example of these chemical accidents is the formation of cataracts on the lens of the eye. Once again, crosslinking of the proteins of the eye lens has been found to play a role in the growth of cataracts, which can be simply formed in the laboratory by leaving an intact animal lens in a sugar solution. Cataracts are particularly common amongst diabetics, whose high blood sugar speeds up the rate of cataract formation.

The fundamental aim of the Marsden research programme was to unravel the chemical mechanisms of protein crosslinking, with the long term goal of determining methods to control this process. A large amount of work has taken place around the world, as well as in Dr Gerrard's laboratory. It is now well-established that the main culprits are in fact breakdown products of sugars that form naturally in the body, notably a small molecule called methylglyoxal. The Canterbury team has made a substantial contribution to this advance in knowledge. In particular, they have identified key structural features of molecules that are likely to make them damaging, and shown that each of the molecules likely to be responsible for the harmful reactions with proteins reacts in a unique way.
With so many different molecules involved, the situation is far more complex than the originally envisaged association of a sugar with a protein. There is hope that inhibitors can be used to trap methylglyoxal and related molecules before damage occurs. But much more fundamental science remains to be done in this area before its potential applications in medicine can be fully exploited.
But protein crosslinking is not all bad news. Crosslinked proteins have been found to favourably alter the texture of food. For example, if a crosslinking enzyme is included in flour that is used to make croissants, the difference in volume and "airiness" can be dramatic (see illustration on page 2).

Addition of a crosslinking enzyme transglutaminase (TGA)
produces an impressive improvement in the size and texture
of the treated croissant (left) as opposed to the untreated (right).
Photograph: Robert Lambert

Dr Gerrard's group works closely with the Food and Biomaterials Innovation Team at Crop & Food Research, Lincoln, in a related research programme to explore the potential benefits of protein crosslinking in food. The Marsden Programme included a subcontract to Crop & Food Research, which investigated ways of manipulating the Maillard reaction during food processing. A basic understanding of the way in which proteins and sugar react may one day have huge benefits in both medicine and food science.


Tuatara survivors

R. E. Barwick

Tuatara are the only survivors of a line of reptiles that died out 200 million years ago. They have survived continental drift, asteroid wipeouts and Ice Ages to become one of the world's archetypal "living fossils".
Until 1990, we supposed that all tuatara were the same but, in that year, Victoria University's Professor Charles Daugherty confirmed that we had two species - the common tuatara, which lives on 25 offshore islands, and Gunther's or the Brothers Island tuatara, which lives only on North Brother Island, Cook Strait. Most islands have only a handful of tuatara but Stephens Island in Cook Strait is exceptional. It has between 30,000 and 50,000 tuatara.
Fossil bones show that tuatara once lived from Northland to Southland but Pacific rats, brought here by Maori, and more lethal predators released by Europeans, ate tuatara off mainland New Zealand in the 1800s. Today, conservationists, Maori, and the general public would like to see tuatara restored to their old island homes and to the mainland. The Marsden Fund aims to promote this goal by supporting research on the species.
To this end, Professor Daugherty's team has taken about 150 tuatara eggs from North Brother Island and hatched them in incubators at Victoria University. The hatchlings are reared in a $40,000 predator-proof enclosure funded by San Diego Zoo, which has a special interest in conserving reptiles.
Young tuatara have been successfully released on predator-free Matiu-Somes Island in Wellington Harbour, Titi Island in Marlborough Sounds, and Moutohora Island off Whangarei.

430 tuatara hatchlings from Stephens Island are currently being reared in a head start facility in Wellington. It is hoped that these animals will be released in a few years' time on the Rangitotos - three islands in the Marlborough Sounds recently cleared of predators. Some day, tuatara may also be released on Mana Island, off Paremata, and in Wellington City's Karori Wildlife Sanctuary.
Relocating tuatara has raised some practical questions. For example, are artificially incubated tuatara as fit as those from natural nests? To test this, Marsden-funded doctoral student, Nicky Nelson, has been comparing the behaviour of wild and lab-incubated tuatara - their reactions to artificial moreporks, their readiness to eat, their sprinting ability, and their survivorship. "We want to make sure our method of producing young tuatara is as good as it can be," says Nicky.
Then there is the question of tuatara sex ratios. It was long supposed that, like most animals, half a tuatara's eggs hatched as males and half as females. Not so. The sex ratio of hatchlings depends on the temperature at which they are incubated. Nicky Nelson finds that Stephens Island tuatara have a physiological switch that turns on somewhere between 21 and 22°C. If the eggs are incubated at 21°C or lower, most eggs hatch as females. At 22°C and above, all hatch as males. Somewhere between 21 and 22°C they hatch half males and half females.
Crocodiles work on the same system. This is an odd set-up, but it seems that's how reptiles have done things for 200 million years. We have yet to discover if the sex ratio switch is set at different temperatures in different places, and to discover the optimum sex ratios of tuatara to be released at new sites.
Another emerging question for researchers is global warming. Will female tuatara respond to warmer temperatures by changing their nesting behaviour to choose cooler sites? Will temperatures in nests become lethal among some small populations where the choice of nest sites is limited? Global warming may upset the balance of the sexes and threaten the future of this hardy survivor.

For further information, contact Professor Charles Daugherty, School of Biological Sciences, Victoria University of Wellington, P. O. Box 600, Wellington - Tel: (04) 463 5572 Email: charles.daugherty@vuw.ac.nz


News from Marsden Cottage

by Dr Valda McCann, Manager, Research Funding

Progress of the assessment process
The first set of referees' reports was sent out to applicants on 27 June and that represented 88% of the reports promised by referees. Since then, reports have been arriving steadily and these will be sent out to applicants for comment. We will try to get the remaining reports right up to the panel meetings in August and, similarly, we will source applicants' comments where time permits. About two-thirds of the people we ask to referee proposals are able to do so, which means that we have sent requests to about 750 people. We attempt to get at least three referees for each proposal.

Personal news
I have made the "big decision" to retire at the end of August this year, so this is my last "News from Marsden Cottage". Early in 1997, I joined the Marsden staff of Mike Prebble (manager) and Meredith O'Brien (administration officer). Under Mike's able leadership we had an enjoyable time starting to set up some new systems for the Fund. Tragically, Mike died in April 1998 and the next year was very difficult, especially the first 6 months when Meredith and I were the only staff members.
As I look back over the five and a half years I have worked with the Marsden Fund, I see that there have been many changes. I thought it would be interesting to list some of them as it is easy to take the present situation for granted.
Funding The Fund has almost tripled. In 1997, the Fund was $11 million - it is now $30.8 million with a consequent increase in the number of current contracts.
New funding category In 2001, a new Fast-Start programme was set up, targeted at researchers starting off their careers in a staff position at a research institution. This is intended to provide a stimulus to research at that important early phase when new job requirements limit the time that can be spent on research.
Publicity When I first joined the Royal Society, the newsletters used to give a summary of the results of the application process and comments from the Marsden Fund Committee on the breadth and merit of the applications. As I visited research groups, I asked them to write a few paragraphs on their work and these were added to the newsletter. Since then it has progressed to being mainly a vehicle for letting others know about Marsden research and an important information source for articles appearing in the media.
We make an effort to let the media know directly about Marsden research. If people don't know about our successes, they are less likely to support expenditure of public money in this area. Starting in 1998, we have had several public functions, including one in Parliament, to celebrate and publicise research supported by the Marsden Fund.
Characteristics of principal and associate investigators In 1997, we did not have information on the research experience and other characteristics of successful applicants. We now have a good profile of these applicants. About one-third of all principal investigators and associate investigators are within 10 years of receiving their PhD degrees. This is a higher proportion than expected from the data on the age profile of the science population and should get rid of the myth that only very experienced researchers are successful in gaining funding. Women have become increasingly successful in gaining funding - the proportion of principal investigators who are women has risen from 6% in 1995 to 25% in the 2001 round, about the percentage of women scientists. For contracts in place last year, the percentage of principal and associate investigators who are Maori is approximately 2%, although Maori researchers contributed to 5% of the contracts. In a 1997 Royal Society survey only 0.7% of scientists were identified as Maori, so the level of participation is consistent with this.
Monitoring of research This began in 1997 and has grown since then. It provides an essential dialogue between the Marsden staff and researchers and a means of understanding the breadth of the research and important outcomes. It also provides an invaluable communication link to work through problems that occur during the progress of the research.
International links We have good links with international funding agencies. Last year, Professor Diana Hill and I visited more than 20 agencies in 7 different countries. These links are most important in ensuring that we keep up with best international practice in funding research. The people in these agencies are always ready to assist, for example when we have a problem in finding referees for a very specialised proposal.
Referee database Over the last few years, we have developed a database of referees. I would like to see this increase in size in the next few years, as we have to cope with such a wide range of topics. In 1997, only 40% of the full proposals had 3 or more referees. Since 1998 that percentage has usually been over 90. In order to keep up with international standards and to avoid conflicts of interest, about 80-85% of our referees are from outside New Zealand.
Jobs website In September 2000, we set up a web page to list positions for postdoctoral fellows and postgraduate students on Marsden research programmes. Nearly 90 positions have been listed. The success of this will depend on researchers contacting us about vacancies and also telling students about the website. So spread the word! http://www.rsnz.org/funding/marsden_fund/
Farewell and thanks
The prestige of the Fund has risen over the years. New Zealand researchers are not in an easy funding environment - problems in finding postgraduate students or postdoctoral fellows, university heads of departments who do not understand the implications that some of their staff's time is being externally funded, and so on. Nevertheless the quality of research is very high. Increasingly, the Fund is having to find ways of assessing the effectiveness of research grants as it is accountable to the Government for the expenditure. Researchers, therefore, need to provide us with good quality information. The up-side of this is that the effectiveness of the grants becomes part of an argument in trying to get increased funding for such research.
I am very grateful to the Marsden staff - Peter Gilberd, Rachel Averill, Rochelle Barton and, recently, Cameron Crabb - who work very hard and with great dedication.
We could not operate without outside help. The first Marsden Update editor, Redmer Yska, saw it through its development stage, and Bob Brockie has assisted more recently. We would certainly be lost without the database development by Jim Quickenden, as this is the source of our information about the Fund and all the processes for managing the funding round, our jobs website and so on. There are many people I haven't mentioned but the list would go on too long. The other staff members of the Royal Society are also very supportive of our work.
For the future, there are already several projects in progress: Peter Gilberd and Rachel Averill have been setting up an electronic form for annual reporting to make it easier for researchers to write the reports and for Marsden staff to read them, with selected information going automatically into the database; a database of publications from Marsden research that will be accessible on the web; further development of methods to assess the impact of the Fund - the new ideas generated, training of emerging researchers, and measures of research quality, including citation information on publications and so on. Andrea Knox, the evaluation officer for the Society, has been working on access to bibliometric information.
Over these years, more than 200 people have served on assessment panels or the committee. Their task is not easy and comes with little personal reward. I am always amazed at the dedication and goodwill that is shown. I have appreciated meeting and working with this group of people and thank them all, in particular those who have had the larger task of being on the committee.
For the Fund to operate effectively, we depend on the good relationships built up with research offices around the country. The interaction is always enjoyable and helpful, and we are grateful for that.
To all Marsden researchers - thank you all for your cooperation. Please keep the successful research stories coming and let us know about any breakthroughs that should be publicised and any flow-on effects of the research. Only if the Fund is seen to be making important and worthwhile contributions to New Zealand's future will it grow in size.
I have enjoyed knowing about the vast range and quality of research that is carried out under the auspices of the Marsden Fund and meeting the people involved, but I am sure I will enjoy the next phase too. My partner and I are now novice yachties. I am attending a course on diesel engines where we learn a new way every week for the boat to sink in a few minutes. Despite that - the sea beckons.


Using DNA to track dolphin and whale populations

Auckland biologist, Associate Professor Scott Baker, has been studying whales and dolphins for nearly 25 years. For the last 15 years, he has collected DNA from the skin of living whales, and from beachcast and museum specimens, to study their genetic diversity.
As leader of the Ecology and Evolution Group at The University of Auckland, Associate Professor Baker, along with colleagues worldwide, and a string of PhD students, has built up a huge database on the genetics of these animals.

Hector's Dolphin mother and calf Photograph: Steve Dawson

You might remember that, back in 1993, Professor Baker was involved in identifying species of whale meat in Tokyo shops. He had to do the DNA work in a Tokyo hotel room as customs regulations prevented him from bringing samples back to New Zealand to analyse. With the help of his former postdoctoral fellow, Dr. Gina Lento, this molecular monitoring has been continued since 1993 and has identified the specific origin of more than 1100 products from 26 species of whales, dolphins and porpoises. This, despite the fact that species such as the humpback, gray, sei, fin, and Bryde's whales have been protected for decades.
The ever-widening database is being put to many uses. Together with former Marsden postdoctoral fellow Dr Luis Medrano (now at the University of Mexico) and Dr Brad Congdon (now at James Cook University, Cairns), Professor Baker has described the interchange of genes among humpback whales around the world. His former student Dr Merel Dalebout, and colleagues at Museum of New Zealand (Te Papa) and the Smithsonian Institution, have discovered a new species of beaked whale from the North Pacific. They have also rediscovered a forgotten species of beaked whale by using DNA to establish the genetic identity of a tooth and a jaw found on the Chatham Islands in the 1870s and a skull cast up on White Island in the 1950s.
With his former student Dr Franz Pichler, his current student Kirsty Russell, and colleagues from the University of Otago, Professor Baker has recently focused on the genetic diversity of the world's rarest sea-going dolphin - Hector's dolphin. These dolphins are divided into four populations - the South Island west coast, south coast and east coast and the North Island west coast. Once, dolphins from these populations exchanged genes through occasional migration and interbreeding, but now the populations are isolated from each other. In some places their numbers are falling as a result of accidental drowning in fishnets. This is of grave concern as fewer than a hundred North Island dolphins are left.
As a result of this study, Professor Baker and his team became interested in the effects of population fragmentation on the dolphin's genetic diversity. Using methods developed for 'ancient' samples, they extracted DNA from museum specimens going back to 1870, and took samples from hundreds of living dolphins (by approaching them in the open sea and gently scraping their skins with a plastic pot cleaner). They examined the maternally inherited mitochondrial (mt) DNA and the genes controlling the dolphins' immune system and compared their diversity with populations of whales and land-going animals worldwide.
They found that populations of Hector's dolphins seem to have become more fragmented and that their genetic diversity has declined along with their numbers in some areas. Along the west coast of the North Island, the range of Hector's dolphins has declined by nearly two thirds over the last 30 years. The small number of dolphins remaining are found primarily off Auckland's west coast, between Raglan and the Kaipara. The researchers warn us that, with such small numbers and the loss of genetic diversity, the Auckland survivors are highly vulnerable to extinction.
Already, legislation is in the pipeline to limit the use of gill-nets off Auckland's west coast. With such a fragmented species, the researchers suggest that it might be possible to restore some genetic diversity by moving dolphins from place to place. Although this strategy has been successfully used with endangered birds, it has never been tried with dolphins before. Dolphin genetic restoration is unknown territory.

For further information, contact Associate Professor Scott Baker, School of Biological Sciences, The University of Auckland, P. O. Box 92019, Auckland - Tel: (09) 373 7599, ext. 7280 Email: cs.baker@auckland.ac.nz

Bringing together museums and indigenous knowledge

Kumete, bowl, with figure supports on a dog, illustrating the story located in Hawaiki of Tamatekapua and Whakaturia stealing the bowl of Uenuku, helped by their dog. The carver was Wero Taroi of Ngati Tarawhai from Lake Okataina, Rotorua. Wero was one of the most famous carvers of the Te Arawa confederation of tribes whose carving career spanned much of the nineteenth century and ranged from war canoes to storehouses, early meeting houses, and the beginnings of tourist art in Rotorua.
Photo: Auckland Museum

New Zealanders and visitors to this country have always realised that Maori woodcarving is a very special art, unique to these islands. Although the Eastern Polynesian origins of Maori art, language and culture are obvious, Maori woodcarving, through its thousand-year history here, has developed its own regional, tribal and individual styles that clearly mark it off from any other Pacific art forms. Maori experience of culture contact and European influence through the nineteenth century intensified these developments and set the scene for the present state of Maori arts.

Some current Marsden-funded research carried out within the project "Bringing Together Museums and Indigenous Knowledge", is demonstrating another aspect of the special qualities of Maori woodcarving. Following on from his recently published work on nineteenth century Rotorua carvers (Carved Histories: Rotorua Ngati Tarawhai Woodcarving, Auckland University Press, 2001), Roger Neich, Professor of Anthropology and Curator of Ethnology at Auckland Museum, has been compiling records of all those nineteenth century Maori carvers whose works can still be identified, in standing meeting houses, in museums, and in archival photographs. So far, about 274 individual carvers, with their tribal affiliations and their works, have been identified, but many unpublished sources are still to be checked. Consultations with the descendants of these carvers are an important source of new insights.
This situation is unique within the nineteenth century ethnic world. Among North-West Coast American Indians about five Haida carvers, some Kwakiutl, and a few others are known, along with their works. For nineteenth century African artists, the record is limited to two or three from the Congo area. In the tropical Pacific, only two from Melanesia and two from Polynesia can be identified.
This amazing wealth of information on Maori carvers can provide the basis for a rich new art history of Maori woodcarving. Utilising these records and adding to them from Maori oral traditions and family records, new insights are being gained into the transmission of carving styles, the relationships between different carving traditions, and the reasons for their survival or demise. Numerous projects for future researchers are emerging from this preliminary study, with implications for a better understanding of nineteenth century cultural and artistic change, not only in New Zealand Maori art but also in other ethnic arts.

For further information, Contact Professor Roger Neich Department of Anthropology, The University of Auckland, Private Bag 92019, Auckland - Tel: (09) 3737 999, ext. 4762 Email: r.neich@auckland.ac.nz

Marsden recognised in Queen's Birthday honours

Professor Diana Hill
Photo courtesy of Otago Daily Times

The Chair of the Marsden Fund Council, Professor Diana Hill, was made a Companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit in the Queen's Birthday honours list, for services to science. Professor Hill is chief executive of Dunedin biotechnology company, Global Technologies, and a member of the Government Biotechnology Taskforce. She is a former Director of the joint AgResearch - University of Otago Molecular Biology Unit.
More so than in the past, the Queen's Birthday Honours list acknowledged the importance of science and research to the wellbeing of New Zealand. At least 10 scientists received awards, including Marsden researchers: Professor Vaughan Jones DCNZM, California (mathematics); Professor Michael Corballis ONZM, Auckland (psychological science); and Dr Jean Fleming ONZM, Dunedin (biological science). The former CEO of the Royal Society of New Zealand, Ross Moore, MNZM, was also recognised.


Frozen weta

Hemideina maori, 7 cm long.

The montane weta, Hemideina maori, is found throughout the South Island, usually at high altitude beneath slabs of schist or in scree. A particularly large variety is found above 4000 ft on the Rock and Pillar Range, about 50 miles north-west of Dunedin. In this environment the temperature may drop below freezing at any time of the year and in winter, temperatures of -7 to -8°C are not uncommon. Beneath the windswept rocks the insects may be exposed to sub-zero temperatures for several days at a time. Associate Professor John Leader and Professor Rob Smith of Otago University received a Marsden grant to see how the weta can survive such conditions.
In the laboratory, Hemideina maori can be frozen to body temperatures of -10°Cfor days. It is readily calculated that, at this temperature, 90% of the body water is ice, and the tissues are then bathed in a saline solution that is about as concentrated as the Dead Sea, which is 10 times that of normal sea water. Metabolism, estimated from oxygen uptake, is reduced to unmeasurable levels, and the principal chemical activity which occurs in the animal is the regrowth of ice crystals and exchange, by diffusion, of potassium from inside the cells with sodium in the concentrated fluids around them.
The frozen insects are quite rigid and brittle. In spite of this, when allowed to rewarm, they thaw and rapidly become active again. Other insects, and indeed some snakes and frogs, are known to tolerate some degree of ice formation within their tissues, but the weta is by far the largest freezing-tolerant insect, and the temperatures it tolerates are far in excess of those endured by vertebrates. Weta lived through the Ice Ages in New Zealand and this particular species may have survived this period by acquiring freezing tolerance. As this country has warmed again and the glaciers have retreated, it has been pushed to the limits of its range, surviving on high mountain tops. In scree slopes at the edge of the Tasman Glacier, the weta can be found in a habitat much like those of earlier times, freezing at night and becoming active by day.
An important feature of the freeze-tolerance of this insect lies in its blood composition. Like most freeze-tolerant animals, the weta contains high concentrations of the sugar trehalose and an amino acid, proline. In summer, trehalose concentrations in the blood are similar to those of other insects, but in winter it may reach as high as 100 grams per litre. Trehalose is a disaccharide, comprising two molecules of glucose joined together. Possession of high concentrations of trehalose is a common feature of a wide range of organisms exposed to water stress, either as a result of dehydration or low temperature.
It is possible to mimic the processes which occur during freezing by using isolated tissues of the weta. Recent experiments by the researchers suggest that trehalose (and the amino acid proline) is acting in several ways. It helps to retain water around the cellular machinery and prevents cell proteins from being put out of shape by high salt concentrations. Also, concentrated trehalose solutions tend to form a non-crystalline, amorphous glass when frozen, instead of physically destructive ice crystals. The sugar binds to the water molecules and not only prevents ice formation but traps the salts within the matrix, preventing damaging diffusion.
Not all insects with trehalose in their blood are freeze-tolerant. In most insects, trehalose doesn't readily pass through cell membranes, and when it does it is rapidly metabolised. In the weta, however, trehalose can reach high concentrations within cells and this may generate some surprising effects. Two recent reports suggest that when trehalose is raised to high concentrations in mammalian cells in tissue culture by artificial engineering, the cells become tolerant to both freezing and drying. The team has not yet succeeded in demonstrating dehydration tolerance in weta tissues, although the ability to remove almost all the tissue water by freezing suggests that this may be possible. Current experiments are aimed at determining how high intracellular concentrations of trehalose are achieved, and to see if this can be duplicated in other, freezing-susceptible insects.

For further information, contact Associate Professor John Leader, Department of Physiology, University of Otago, P.O. Box 913, Dunedin- Tel: (03) 479 7322 Email: john.leader@stonebow.otago.ac.nz

Marsden Update is published quarterly by the Marsden Fund and is available free on request. Editor: Glenda Lewis Email: glenda.lewis@rsnz.org

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Advisory | Awards | Directory | Education | Events| Funding | Members | News | Publishing | Shop | Topics | Policy |

Problems with the site? Contact the webmaster